Sunday, February 21, 2021

Delhi Police Cover ups

 

Dalit-Online 

Weekly e news paper 

Editor: Nagaraja.M.R.. Vol.17....Issue. 09...............28/02/2021

 

RTI  Appeal  to  Honourable  Delhi  Police  Commissioner 

- Delhi   Police  Cover  up   Crimes  by   Judges

 

Refer : DEPOL/R/E/20/00429

 

Honourable  sir ,

To my previous requests  , you have  not  given  information  requested  and  gave elusive replies, information   just  like  criminals  do during police  interrogation.  Your  denial  of  information  amounts  to  crime cover ups  making  yourselves    criminals.  Please give me information about following under RTI Act :

 

1. Details of action taken against SCI judges  Ranjan Gogoi,  swatantra kumar , Ganguly , Judges involved  in  roost resort sex scandal on charges of sexual  harassment against women. If not reasons for it. Please give me FIR number of each case.

2. List of  public servants  present and past  MPs , IAS & IPS officers, etc   with citizenship of foreign countries in addition to indian citizenship. Also give me list of public servants with spouses of foreign origin.

3. Details of action taken against SCI judge deepak mishra in medical college case , kalikho pul death statement. President of India  Pranab mukherjee was also accused by kalikho  pul. If not reasons for it.

4. Details of our present MPs , IAS & IPS officers facing criminal  charges .

5. Details of  action  taken regarding  charges made by CBI director Alok verma against his deputy Rakesh Asthana and vice versa. If not reasons for it.

6. Details of action taken against police who are aiding underworld don dawood ibrahim. If not reasons for it.

7. Details of action taken against reliance industries in relation to document leak in power , petroleum , coal  ministries. If not reasons for it.

8. Details of action taken against journalists,  lobbyists involved in Radia tape. If not reasons for it.

9. Does Smt.Sonia Gandhi & Shri.Rahul Gandhi have citizenship of foreign countries in addition to indian citizenship. Details please.

10. Does  delhi police use third degree torture against detainees.

11. Details of action taken against  public servants , ministers who aided terrorism at the expense of public exchequer. If not  reasons for it.

 

Please read documents at following web pages and answer :

 

https://www.scribd.com/document/402134326/INTERROGATE-Judges-Police , https://www.scribd.com/document/399783839/India-Sponsored-Terrorists , https://www.scribd.com/document/412164943/CJI-in-Jail ,

 

 

 

Thank you

Nagaraja Mysuru Raghupathi

 

 

Judge's Collusion  with  Bellary  Mining  Mafia ?

     

     In spite of investigation and  reports  by CBI  & Karnataka  Lokayukta  , no clear conviction of karnataka government officials  involved in Bellary Mining scandal  has been taken. Supreme Court of  India is also silent since years despite  appeals for justice in this matter. The corrupt  officials are continuing  in government  service and few of them even got promotions , plum postings for their yeoman ( ? ) service.

 SCI judges have ample time to play golf , tour abroad , take  millions of salary all at tax payer's  expense. Judges have ample time to decide cases relating to movies , sports but not for  cases of national importance.

This attitude of Judge's  and  SCI  points towards complicity of judiciary  in “ Bellary Mining Case cover up".

 

A shame on  SCI Judges.  If at all SCI  Judges are  sincere enough,  let them take appropriate  action  as they do against commoners. Judges & Police exhibit their full force against commoners , roar on them but before mining barons just whimper.

 

Your's Sincerely

NAGARAJA  MYSURU RAGHUPATHI

 

 

PIL – Legal Prosecution of officials involved in Bellary Mining Scam

 

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA ORIGINAL JURISDICTION



CRIMINAL WRIT PETITION NO. OF 2015





IN THE MATTER OF



NAGARAJA . M.R  ,

editor  ,  SOS e  Clarion  of   Dalit  &  SOS  e  Voice  for  Justice , 

# LIG 2 , No 761 , HUDCO First Stage , Laxmikantanagar ,

Hebbal , Mysore – 570017 , Karnataka State

.....Petitioner



Versus



Honourable Chief  Secretary , Government of Karnataka  & Others

....Respondents





PETITION UNDER ARTICLE 12 to ARTICLE 35 & ARTICLE 51A OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA FOR ISSUANCE OF A WRIT IN THE NATURE OF

MANDAMUS UNDER ARTICLE 32 & ARTICLE 226 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA.





To ,



Hon'ble The Chief Justice of India and His Lordship's Companion

Justices of the Supreme Court of India. The Humble petition of the Petitioner above named.





MOST RESPECTFULLY SHOWETH :



1. Facts of the case:

Our  whole hearted respects  to honest few in judiciary , parliament & public service. Our salutes to them , due to  honest efforts of those few  noble persons only at least democracy is surviving in India.

A .  "Power will go to the hands of rascals, , rogues and freebooters. All Indian leaders will be of low calibre and men of straw. They will have sweet tongues and silly hearts. They will fight among themselves for power and will be lost in political squabbles . A day would come when even air & water will be taxed." Sir Winston made this statement in the House of Commons just before the independence of India & Pakistan. Sadly , the forewarning of Late Winston Churchill has been proved right by some of our criminal , corrupt people’s representatives , police , public servants & Judges. Some of the below mentioned judges fall among the category of churchill’s men – Rogues , Rascals & Freebooters.

B . Loot of natural resources in Karnataka state  and  illegal aid  to  those criminals by government officials. Read  Karnataka Lokayukta Mining scam report .



2. Question(s) of Law:

Are  forest officials , police & revenue officials who aided  bellary mining loot ,  above Law & can go scot free ? 



3. Grounds:

Requests for equitable justice , legal prosecution & punishment of guilty police , revenue , forest officials. 


4. Averment:

GIVE WHAT ACTION HAS BEEN TAKEN AGAINST THE GUILTY  GOVERNMENT OFFICIALS  MENTIONED  IN THE KARNATAKA LOKAYUKTA REPORT  submitted by Justice Santosh Hegde &  Shri.U.V.Singh ABOUT BELLARY MINING SCAM. IF NOT WHY ?  REASONS THEROF.

How many guilty government officials mentioned in the above report  got promotions , continuing in service making it easy for them to tamper evidences ?

What action against  public servants , officials who are hushing up the case & protecting the guilty ?

The Petitioner has sent many letters / appeals / petitions to supreme court of india & other courts through e-mail , DARPG website & through regular mail requesting them to consider those as PILs. But none of them were admitted , even acknowledgement for receipts were not given. See How duty conscious ,our judges are & see how our judges are sensitive towards life , liberty of citizens , commonmen & see how careless our judges are towards anti national crimes , crimes worth crores of rupees.



That the present petitioner has not filed any other petition (which are admitted by courts) in any High Court or the Supreme Court of India on the subject matter of the present petition.



PRAYER:



In the above premises, it is prayed that this Hon'ble Court may be pleased:

(i) Hereby , I do request the honorable supreme court of India to consider this as a PIL for : “writ of Mandamus” and to issue instructions to the concerned public servants in the following cases to perform their duties & to answer the questions.

(ii) Hereby , I do request  the honourble supreme court of india to  legally prosecute  guilty officials  mentioned in the above said report.

(iii) Hereby , I do request  the honourble supreme court of india  to uphold the constitution of india  , to protect natural resources and to protect the constitutional rights of all Indian citizens including mine.


(iv) Hereby , I do request  the honourble supreme court of india  to  immediately keep all government officials mentioned in the above said report under suspension from service & to take necessary steps to protect all type of evidences.


(v) to pass such other orders and further orders as may be deemed necessary on the facts and in the circumstances of the case.



FOR WHICH ACT OF KINDNESS, THE PETITIONER SHALL BE DUTY BOUND, EVER PRAY.



Date :  04th November  2015………………………………Filed By : Nagaraja.M.R.

Place : Mysuru India……………………………………Petitioner in person

 

 

Judge's Collegium or Mafia ?

-          An Appeal to Honourable Supreme Court of India

 

Former Chief  Justice of India Mr.Ranjan gogoi got  wisdom after retirement. He clearly said it is doubtful to get justice in indian courts nowadays.  What is the fate of common man ?

 

In spite of repeated appeals to  SCI judges  regarding  accountability of judges & police , they are acting  deaf , dumb & blind. They are not doing  their  constitutional  duties properly for which they are paid for. We once again request you to read the sample cases mentioned  at below websites  and  to do their constitutional  duties  properly  instead of  cover ups & silencing  applicant.

 

Thank you

Nagaraja  Mysuru Raghupathi

 

 

Editorial : Duping  SCI  Judge’s  Collegium

 

            Recent   decision  of  SCI  collegium’s  move  to make public  the  reasons behind  elevation , non elevation or transfer of judges is a welcome move. But it gives out only  half truth.  SCI   website  gives out observations of  peer  judges  , observations of Intelligence Bureau.  It doesn’t spell out  on the basis of which facts , which cases  IB  or  Peer Judges  gave their observations.  Those actual facts must be made public and  the persons effected by  wrong judgement  of  judges in question  must be  given justice first  by correcting it. Second the said  judge is not only  unfit for elevation , he is  even unfit to continue in the present post as he will mete out more injustices to public. Third the said judge must be removed from service & legally prosecuted for crimes.

              When a peer  judge has a caste bias  or  doesn’t like a colleague , definitely  he will have negative  observation towards that colleague. Also the Intelligence Bureau  gives out observation favorable to  powers that be. That is why  generalized   observations of anybody is not right , it must be backed by facts , case details.

              This is the very reason  merited  , honest  advocates  , judges belonging to backward castes , weaker sections of  society  are not adequately considered for elevation of judges or for induction of judges from bar.  Whereas judges having  serious allegations against them  still gets elevated on the basis of backing from powers that be.  Many relatives of  judges gets the posting.  While honest  judges who uphold  law and  take to task the  ruling government for their wrongdoings are  denied promotions , victimized. Whereas  judges in  good books with ruling government  inspite  of serious  allegations  against them get promotions.

               Say , in a case before court  ‘A’   simply accuses “B”  of a  theft , will the court accept it. Say a commonman accuses a judge or police  of corruption , will the  trial court   judge accept it . Trial court judge demands  facts backing   the accusations.  In the same way ,  SCI  Collegium   must publicize the facts  behind  their reasoning  not mere observations of some tom , dick & harry. If at all their present practice is right  we too have a observation “  If present Chief Justice of India  is  UNFIT for the constitutional position of CJI. Will he , collegiums or SCI accept it and remove  him  from his post based on mere observations ?

             The powers that be  have made a calculated move to deceive the public , as more & more public , learned advocates started demanding accountability of judges from  SCI Collegium. Now they  have mentioned only HALF TRUTHS , why not full truth ? why cut off date from 03.10.2017 only  ? why not from 1990s  till date including recent elevation of  Judges ?

             Judges enjoy  5 star pay , perks ,  Air Conditioned bungalows , Air conditioned cars , flight travel , 5 star hospital facility , etc all  at poor tax  payer’s expense. Is it not a SHAME that they don’t give account of their duties , actions to the very same tax payer.  Theses judges  think they are the only wise men on earth and all the poor tax payers are fools.  Collegium is not doing a favor by publishing  half truth reasons  on web sites. Sharing information with the public is  the duty of every public servant including judges. Information  forms part of Expression and  is guaranteed  under Fundamental Right to Freedom of Expression as well as Human Right of Freedom of Expression. It is not a favor by any judges.  Constitution of India is above all , Judges are below it.

            Why  not  collegiums  make public announcement  of vacancies  with the eligibility criteria needed .   Then serving judges as well as learned advocates from bar  can face the recruitment process and  based on ranking  final selection can be made.  Then we will  get  few honest judges who have guts  to uphold constitution of india  inspite of  obstacles from powers that be , ruling government.

             SCI  Judges are not considering  our  PILs  since years. First  let  the  Judges  first respect  RTI  Act  and give  full , correct , truthful answers to  our RTI  Questionnaire  pending before them since years. Hereby , we demand  SCI  Collegium  to ANSWER  our  Show-Cause Notice to CJI and  RTI  Questions at following web pages and thereby uphold  national security , constitution of india.

JAI  HIND.  VANDE  MATARAM.

 

Your’s  sincerely ,

Nagaraja Mysuru Raghupathi.

 

 

Traitors  in  Judiciary &  Police

https://www.scribd.com/document/329980170/Traitors-in-Judiciary-Police   ,

 

Crimes  by  Khaki

https://sites.google.com/site/sosevoiceforjustice/crimes-by-khaki

 

FIRST  Answer  Judges  Police

https://www.scribd.com/document/336585411/FIRST-Answer-Judges-Police  

 

Public Prosecutor   Appointment Scam

http://starofmysore.com/assistant-public-prosecutors-appointment-scam-unearthed/  ,

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WAEBJsp_Zsg ,

 

Four Arrested in  Delhi Police Recruitment Scam

http://indianexpress.com/article/india/india-news-india/four-arrested-in-delhi-police-recruitment-scam-2998152/ ,

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vyapam_scam  ,

 

KPSC  , Scam

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/indiahome/indianews/article-2362317/CID-probe-exposes-jobs-marriage-scam-KPSC.html  ,

http://bangalore.citizenmatters.in/articles/kpsc-recruitment-scam-cid-report-confirms-malpractice ,

 

Judge   Selection   Illegal

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/indiahome/indianews/article-3300929/Did-judges-children-special-treatment-Supreme-Court-examine-answer-sheets-Delhi-judicial-exam-2014-favouritism-complaints.html   ,

http://www.timesnow.tv/india/video/sc-judge-rips-into-cji-headed-collegium-shuns-selection-meetings/48804 ,

http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/kochi/Discrepancies-in-magistrate-test-evaluation-HC-asks-for-registrys-views/articleshow/46470410.cms  ,

 

Top police official in Kerala allegedly caught red-handed while copying in LL.M. exam

http://www.livelaw.in/top-police-official-in-kerala-allegedly-caught-red-handed-while-copying-in-ll-m-exam/ ,

 

Judges Suspended For Mass Copying

http://news.fullhyderabad.com/hyderabad-news/five-judges-suspended-for-mass-copying-1434.html ,

 

https://sites.google.com/site/eclarionofdalit/wheeling-dealing-judges-police  ,  

 

 Atrocities on  Women  by  JUDGES

https://sites.google.com/site/eclarionofdalit/atrocities-by-judges ,

   

   A – Z   of   Manipulation  of  Indian  Legal  System

http://www.scribd.com/doc/187575206/A-Z-of-Manipulation-of-India-Legal-System ,

http://www.scribd.com/doc/173854541/Chief-Justice-of-India-A-Criminal  ,

 

Justice  Sathasivam -  Are  you  DEAF  DUMB  &  BLIND

https://sites.google.com/site/eclarionofdalit/justice-sathasivam---are-you-deaf-dumb-blind ,   

 

Rajiv Gandhi Assassination Cover-up

https://sites.google.com/site/sosevoiceforjustice/rajiv-gandhi-assassination-cover-up ,

 

SHAME  SHAME  MPs  &  MLAs

https://sites.google.com/site/sosevoiceforjustice/shame-shame-mps-mlas   ,

 

Cropping Up Of SC Judge’s Name During Inquiry Is No Reason To Stall Probe Against Orissa HC Judge, CJAR Writes To In-House Committee Chairman

Read more at: http://www.livelaw.in/cropping-sc-judges-name-inquiry-no-reason-stall-probe-orissa-hc-judge-cjar-writes-house-committee-chairman/

 

Intellectual Dishonesty Is The Biggest Challenge To The Independence Of Judiciary: Senior Advocate Dushyant Dave 

Read more at: http://www.livelaw.in/intellectual-dishonesty-biggest-challenge-independence-judiciary-senior-advocate-dushyant-dave-video /  ,

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YiqRt9YsYhQ&t=825s  ,

 

Why The kith And Kin Of Judges Being Mostly Considered For Appointments? Asks SCBA President

http://www.livelaw.in/kith-kin-judges-mostly-considered-appointments-asks-scba-president-judges-child-calibre-heshe-can-become-judge-cji/ ,

 

 

Edited, printed , published owned by NAGARAJA.M.R. @  # LIG-2   No  761, HUDCO  FIRST  STAGE , OPP WATER WORKS , LAXMIKANTANAGAR , HEBBAL

,MYSURU – 570017  KARNATAKA  INDIA     Cell : 91 8970318202

  WhatsApp  91  8970318202

 

 

Home page :

http://eclarionofdalit.dalitonline.in        

https://dalit-online.blogspot.com     

 

 Contact  :  editor@dalitonline.in   ,

 editor.dalitonline@gmail.com

 

 

About Me

My photo

Dalit-Online

View my complete profile

Powered by Blogger.

 

 

Saturday, February 20, 2021

Judge's Mafia !

 

Dalit-Online 

Weekly e news paper 

Editor: Nagaraja.M.R.. Vol.17....Issue. 08...............21/02/2021

 

Judge's Collegium or Mafia ?

-          An Appeal to Honourable Supreme Court of India

 

Former Chief  Justice of India Mr.Ranjan gogoi got  wisdom after retirement. He clearly said it is doubtful to get justice in indian courts nowadays.  What is the fate of common man ?

 

In spite of repeated appeals to  SCI judges  regarding  accountability of judges & police , they are acting  deaf , dumb & blind. They are not doing  their  constitutional  duties properly for which they are paid for. We once again request you to read the sample cases mentioned  at below websites  and  to do their constitutional  duties  properly  instead of  cover ups & silencing  applicant.

 

Thank you

Nagaraja  Mysuru Raghupathi

 

 

Editorial : Duping  SCI  Judge’s  Collegium

 

            Recent   decision  of  SCI  collegium’s  move  to make public  the  reasons behind  elevation , non elevation or transfer of judges is a welcome move. But it gives out only  half truth.  SCI   website  gives out observations of  peer  judges  , observations of Intelligence Bureau.  It doesn’t spell out  on the basis of which facts , which cases  IB  or  Peer Judges  gave their observations.  Those actual facts must be made public and  the persons effected by  wrong judgement  of  judges in question  must be  given justice first  by correcting it. Second the said  judge is not only  unfit for elevation , he is  even unfit to continue in the present post as he will mete out more injustices to public. Third the said judge must be removed from service & legally prosecuted for crimes.

              When a peer  judge has a caste bias  or  doesn’t like a colleague , definitely  he will have negative  observation towards that colleague. Also the Intelligence Bureau  gives out observation favorable to  powers that be. That is why  generalized   observations of anybody is not right , it must be backed by facts , case details.

              This is the very reason  merited  , honest  advocates  , judges belonging to backward castes , weaker sections of  society  are not adequately considered for elevation of judges or for induction of judges from bar.  Whereas judges having  serious allegations against them  still gets elevated on the basis of backing from powers that be.  Many relatives of  judges gets the posting.  While honest  judges who uphold  law and  take to task the  ruling government for their wrongdoings are  denied promotions , victimized. Whereas  judges in  good books with ruling government  inspite  of serious  allegations  against them get promotions.

               Say , in a case before court  ‘A’   simply accuses “B”  of a  theft , will the court accept it. Say a commonman accuses a judge or police  of corruption , will the  trial court   judge accept it . Trial court judge demands  facts backing   the accusations.  In the same way ,  SCI  Collegium   must publicize the facts  behind  their reasoning  not mere observations of some tom , dick & harry. If at all their present practice is right  we too have a observation “  If present Chief Justice of India  is  UNFIT for the constitutional position of CJI. Will he , collegiums or SCI accept it and remove  him  from his post based on mere observations ?

             The powers that be  have made a calculated move to deceive the public , as more & more public , learned advocates started demanding accountability of judges from  SCI Collegium. Now they  have mentioned only HALF TRUTHS , why not full truth ? why cut off date from 03.10.2017 only  ? why not from 1990s  till date including recent elevation of  Judges ?

             Judges enjoy  5 star pay , perks ,  Air Conditioned bungalows , Air conditioned cars , flight travel , 5 star hospital facility , etc all  at poor tax  payer’s expense. Is it not a SHAME that they don’t give account of their duties , actions to the very same tax payer.  Theses judges  think they are the only wise men on earth and all the poor tax payers are fools.  Collegium is not doing a favor by publishing  half truth reasons  on web sites. Sharing information with the public is  the duty of every public servant including judges. Information  forms part of Expression and  is guaranteed  under Fundamental Right to Freedom of Expression as well as Human Right of Freedom of Expression. It is not a favor by any judges.  Constitution of India is above all , Judges are below it.

            Why  not  collegiums  make public announcement  of vacancies  with the eligibility criteria needed .   Then serving judges as well as learned advocates from bar  can face the recruitment process and  based on ranking  final selection can be made.  Then we will  get  few honest judges who have guts  to uphold constitution of india  inspite of  obstacles from powers that be , ruling government.

             SCI  Judges are not considering  our  PILs  since years. First  let  the  Judges  first respect  RTI  Act  and give  full , correct , truthful answers to  our RTI  Questionnaire  pending before them since years. Hereby , we demand  SCI  Collegium  to ANSWER  our  Show-Cause Notice to CJI and  RTI  Questions at following web pages and thereby uphold  national security , constitution of india.

JAI  HIND.  VANDE  MATARAM.

 

Your’s  sincerely ,

Nagaraja Mysuru Raghupathi.

 

 

Traitors  in  Judiciary &  Police

https://www.scribd.com/document/329980170/Traitors-in-Judiciary-Police   ,

 

Crimes  by  Khaki

https://sites.google.com/site/sosevoiceforjustice/crimes-by-khaki

 

FIRST  Answer  Judges  Police

https://www.scribd.com/document/336585411/FIRST-Answer-Judges-Police  

 

Public Prosecutor   Appointment Scam

http://starofmysore.com/assistant-public-prosecutors-appointment-scam-unearthed/  ,

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WAEBJsp_Zsg ,

 

Four Arrested in  Delhi Police Recruitment Scam

http://indianexpress.com/article/india/india-news-india/four-arrested-in-delhi-police-recruitment-scam-2998152/ ,

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vyapam_scam  ,

 

KPSC  , Scam

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/indiahome/indianews/article-2362317/CID-probe-exposes-jobs-marriage-scam-KPSC.html  ,

http://bangalore.citizenmatters.in/articles/kpsc-recruitment-scam-cid-report-confirms-malpractice ,

 

Judge   Selection   Illegal

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/indiahome/indianews/article-3300929/Did-judges-children-special-treatment-Supreme-Court-examine-answer-sheets-Delhi-judicial-exam-2014-favouritism-complaints.html   ,

http://www.timesnow.tv/india/video/sc-judge-rips-into-cji-headed-collegium-shuns-selection-meetings/48804 ,

http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/kochi/Discrepancies-in-magistrate-test-evaluation-HC-asks-for-registrys-views/articleshow/46470410.cms  ,

 

Top police official in Kerala allegedly caught red-handed while copying in LL.M. exam

http://www.livelaw.in/top-police-official-in-kerala-allegedly-caught-red-handed-while-copying-in-ll-m-exam/ ,

 

Judges Suspended For Mass Copying

http://news.fullhyderabad.com/hyderabad-news/five-judges-suspended-for-mass-copying-1434.html ,

 

https://sites.google.com/site/eclarionofdalit/wheeling-dealing-judges-police  ,  

 

 Atrocities on  Women  by  JUDGES

https://sites.google.com/site/eclarionofdalit/atrocities-by-judges ,

   

   A – Z   of   Manipulation  of  Indian  Legal  System

http://www.scribd.com/doc/187575206/A-Z-of-Manipulation-of-India-Legal-System ,

http://www.scribd.com/doc/173854541/Chief-Justice-of-India-A-Criminal  ,

 

Justice  Sathasivam -  Are  you  DEAF  DUMB  &  BLIND

https://sites.google.com/site/eclarionofdalit/justice-sathasivam---are-you-deaf-dumb-blind ,   

 

Rajiv Gandhi Assassination Cover-up

https://sites.google.com/site/sosevoiceforjustice/rajiv-gandhi-assassination-cover-up ,

 

SHAME  SHAME  MPs  &  MLAs

https://sites.google.com/site/sosevoiceforjustice/shame-shame-mps-mlas   ,

 

Cropping Up Of SC Judge’s Name During Inquiry Is No Reason To Stall Probe Against Orissa HC Judge, CJAR Writes To In-House Committee Chairman

Read more at: http://www.livelaw.in/cropping-sc-judges-name-inquiry-no-reason-stall-probe-orissa-hc-judge-cjar-writes-house-committee-chairman/

 

Intellectual Dishonesty Is The Biggest Challenge To The Independence Of Judiciary: Senior Advocate Dushyant Dave 

Read more at: http://www.livelaw.in/intellectual-dishonesty-biggest-challenge-independence-judiciary-senior-advocate-dushyant-dave-video /  ,

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YiqRt9YsYhQ&t=825s  ,

 

Why The kith And Kin Of Judges Being Mostly Considered For Appointments? Asks SCBA President

http://www.livelaw.in/kith-kin-judges-mostly-considered-appointments-asks-scba-president-judges-child-calibre-heshe-can-become-judge-cji/ ,

 

 

Edited, printed , published owned by NAGARAJA.M.R. @  # LIG-2   No  761, HUDCO  FIRST  STAGE , OPP WATER WORKS , LAXMIKANTANAGAR , HEBBAL

,MYSURU – 570017  KARNATAKA  INDIA     Cell : 91 8970318202

  WhatsApp  91  8970318202

 

 

Home page :

http://eclarionofdalit.dalitonline.in        

https://dalit-online.blogspot.com     

 

 Contact  :  editor@dalitonline.in   ,

 editor.dalitonline@gmail.com

 

 

Friday, February 19, 2021

Industrial Pollution in Mysuru

 

Dalit-Online 

Weekly e news paper 

Editor: Nagaraja.M.R.. Vol.17....Issue. 07...............14/02/2021

 

 

Industrial Pollution in Mysuru

-          An appeal to Honourable Supreme Court of India

 

Reckless & greedy attitude of industrialists & bureaucrats  is causing  dumping of industrial waste in and around Mysuru.  Repeated appeals to authorities & SCI  has fallen on deaf ears. Is there quid pro quo ?

Once again we appeal to SCI  to read the  following  cases  carefully  and

1.      To  order authorities  to  prevent further  industrial  waste dumping in & around  Mysuru.

2.      To   order enquiry into young boy Harshel's  murder. Identify the guilt industrialist and to order him to pay compensation to victim's  family.

3.      To order guilty  Industrialist  causing visakhapatnam industrial accident to pay compensation to victims, residents of affected areas.

4.      To order  Industrialists  causing  pollution of kapila  river in Mysuru  district  to pay for it's clean up and  to victims  of Pollution.

5.      To  order  police  to  initiate  criminal prosecution of Industrialists  involved  in  murder of Harshel  , visakhapatnam tragedy & kapila river polluters. 

 

 

Hope this time SCI judges won't act deaf  and will do their  constitutional duties properly.

 

 

With regards

Nagaraja  Mysuru  Raghupathi

Will the government hold Big Polluters liable for air pollution, preventable diseases, and untimely deaths?

By Sandeep Pandey 

 

16.7 lakh people died in India in 2019 because of air pollution accounting for 17·8% of the total deaths in the country (source: The Lancet Planetary Health). Air pollution was the 4th leading risk factor for premature death globally, accounting for nearly 12% of all deaths, with more than 6.67 million in 2019 alone, shows the State of Global Air Report 2020. Each of these deaths could have been averted – and every disease caused by air pollution could have been prevented.

Air pollution is the biggest environmental health crisis we face and the WHO has warned repeatedly that air pollution is an invisible killer. The global death rate attributable to air pollution exposure is 86 deaths per 100,000 people. 92% of the global population lives in places where air pollution levels are above the WHO guideline for healthy air. As we write this article from Lucknow, Air Quality Index here is hovering around 465 (WHO limit is 50).

Air pollution is fuelling epidemics. Of all the deaths caused by ischemic heart disease (biggest killer on our planet) 20% are caused by air pollution. Of all the deaths caused by lung cancer (deadliest of all cancers) 19% are due to air pollution. 40% of COPD deaths are because of air pollution. Asthma is another condition people suffer from which is seriously aggravated by air pollution. Also, let us not forget that other major common risk factors- tobacco and alcohol use- for these diseases are also preventable. Should not our governments hold Big Tobacco and Big Alcohol liable for the irreparable loss of human life and suffering it has caused?

More alarmingly, climate change and air pollution are closely interrelated, further escalating the economic costs and health hazards for humankind. Yet it does not seem to be invoking governments to act with urgency. Air pollution warrants much more urgency to save lives and help people breathe life, and not inhale deadly disease-causing polluted air.

MAKE BIG POLLUTERS PAY

The Lancet Planetary Health published earlier this month further states that lost output from premature deaths and morbidity attributable to air pollution accounted for economic losses of US$ 28·8 billion (about INR 2,13,451 crores) in India in 2019 alone. “The states of Uttar Pradesh and Bihar, with the highest economic loss as a percentage of their GDP, had the lowest per-capita GDP among the states of India, indicating that these poor states are most vulnerable to the adverse economic impacts of air pollution” states The Lancet.

With overburdened and appallingly weak health systems in India, and with additional challenges posed by the Covid-19 pandemic, we cannot afford multiple epidemics of preventable diseases. No one should suffer from any disease that is primarily preventable. Likewise, no one should die prematurely from these curable diseases.

The President of India has recently signed an ordinance, ‘The Commission for Air Quality Management in National Capital Region and adjoining areas, 2020’, with a provision for a fine of INR 1 crore and/or jail for 5 years for those violating air pollution norms. This ordinance has been brought in the background of the problem of stubble burning by farmers. All this while when industrial and vehicular pollution was deteriorating the quality of metropolitan air no government had thought of a strict law to check it. In fact, the history of Pollution Control Boards has been that of compromise on the issue of pollution in exchange for gratification by the Industry. As a proof one has to merely observe the pollution levels in the water bodies situated next to industries or big cities.

We conveniently and squarely blame the poor for pollution but ironically the poor consume and pollute the least. It is us, the privileged people who consume, abuse, and pollute our planet the most. Also, it is us, the privileged people (who live, consume, and pollute in an unsustainable manner) who are getting to decide the ‘sustainable development’ model. So, dumping all blame for air pollution on farmers for stubble-burning is not going to help anyone because we cannot have air purifiers everywhere and we, and our loved ones, need clean air to breathe and live.

Think: Who should be made to pay for these colossal health and economic losses caused by air pollution? Why should not governments recover the economic losses from corporations that have polluted our air? But if we look at past years, governments have diluted, watered down or weakened environmental safeguards for corporations, often in the garb of ‘ease of business’ or the ‘urgency to reboot economy’.

It is the government’s primary responsibility to ensure all citizens breathe clean air. Governments also need to ensure that corporations do not engage in any activity that pollutes our planet and its health, and hold those abusive corporations to account who have harmed our planet or our health in any way. Market-based solutions are not ‘solutions’ but just another way for corporations to fill their coffers. So installing ‘air purifiers’ is not the solution to resolve air pollution but stemming the source(s) of pollution and revamping the development model so that we stop polluting our air and planet, is.

 

 

PIL –  Young Boy  HARSHAL ’s  Death due to Industrial Waste

 

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA ORIGINAL JURISDICTION

 CRIMINAL WRIT PETITION NO. OF 2017

 

 IN THE MATTER OF

 

 NAGARAJA . M.R

 editor SOS e Clarion of Dalit & SOS e Voice for Justice

# LIG 2 , No 761 ,, HUDCO First Stage , Laxmikantanagar ,

Hebbal , Mysore – 570017 , Karnataka State

....Petitioner

 

Versus

 

District Pollution Control Board officer , Mysuru

Joint Director , Department of Industries , Mysuru

Joint Director , KIADB , Mysuru

Deputy Commissioner , Mysuru

& Others

 ....Respondents

 

 PETITION UNDER ARTICLE 12 to ARTICLE 35 & ARTICLE 51A OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA FOR ISSUANCE OF A WRIT IN THE NATURE OF MANDAMUS UNDER ARTICLE 32 & ARTICLE 226 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA.

 

 To ,

Hon'ble The Chief Justice of India and His Lordship's Companion

Justices of the Supreme Court of India.

 

The Humble petition of the   Petitioner above named.

 

MOST RESPECTFULLY SHOWETH :

1.     Facts of the case:

Young  boy  HARSHAL  died  by  burn injuries caused by industrial waste in mysuru , Karnataka.

During  planning of  Industrial Areas in Mysuru , waste dumping yards  were NOT  planned  suitably and  NOT  allocated   sufficient lands for the same , keeping in view  industrial requirements 20 years down the line.

It is like building a house without toilet.

It is criminal negligence of duty by KIADB , Industries department officials  who planned and approved  development  of these industrial sites.

It is criminal negligence of duty by  District Industries department   who gave  license  to these industries in the beginning without physically verifying  about  the waste disposal  methods of these industries.

It is criminal negligence of duty by Karnataka state pollution control board officials  who gave No Objection Certificate to these industries in the beginning without physically verifying  about  the waste disposal  methods of these industries.

 It is criminal negligence of duty by Karnataka state pollution control board officials , District Industries department officials  who  are  renewing   License /  No Objection Certificate to these industries  annually ,  without physically verifying  about  the waste disposal  methods of these industries.

It is criminal negligence of duty by Deputy  Commissioner ,  Mysuru District  to  ensure  adherence  to law by  other department officials.

It is criminal negligence of duty , violation of law , CRIMES  by  responsible Executives  / Owners  of the industries who are  dumping these industrial wastes in a  hush hush manner.

 

 

Read  details at following websites :

http://www.newscrunch.in/2017/04/teenager-dies-earth-suddenly-catches-fire-mysore-%E2%80%93-toxic-waste-dumped-says-official-video   ,

http://starofmysore.com/boy-walks-vacant-plot-loose-soil-succumbs-chemical-burns/http://starofmysore.com/boy-walks-vacant-plot-loose-soil-succumbs-chemical-burns/

http://indiablooms.com/ibns_new/video-details/N/92557/watch-soil-catches-fire-due-to-presence-of-rubber-factory-chemical-waste.html  ,

 

2. Question(s) of Law:

Is  commonman’s   life  so  cheap ,  dispensable ?  If so , why cann’t you  dispense off with the lives of  children  of  PCB , KIADB  officials , Industrialists  ? Are not officials  , Industrialists  accountable for this criminal act of negligence ?

 

3. Grounds:

Requests for equitable justice , Prosecution of  guilty officials ,  Responsible Industry owners.

 4. Averment:

Hereby , I do request the honorable supreme court of India to consider this as a PIL for : “writ of Mandamus” and to issue instructions to the concerned public servants in the  present case, to perform their duties  & to  avert further  loss of lives.

 

PRAYER:

In the above premises, it is prayed that this Hon'ble Court may be pleased:

 

1.     To  order  for   fencing of the  whole area , where  industrial  waste is dumped causing  fire.

2.     To   order  for   24 X 7 police vigil  preventing any tress passers.

3.     To   order  for  supreme court monitored  enquiry , as the industrialists  are high & mighty and may manipulate the  samples itself.

4.     To immediately  order district administration  not to   go ahead  with  spraying other chemicals over the dumping yard  to neutralize the waste chemicals.  As it will alter the samples  and  criminals , guilty industrialists  will  escape.

5.     To  order for sample collection by multiple bodies , NGOs  , so that nobody can manipulate the samples.

6.     After  sample analysis by supreme court empanelled experts ,  based on expert advice steps to diffuse  chemical waste must be taken.

7.     To initiate criminal  prosecution against public  officials  who planned , approved these  industrial area without provision for suitable waste dumping yard.

8.     To order for  criminal prosecution against  guilty industrialists.

9.     To order for criminal prosecution against  KSPCB , KIADB , Industries department officials who gave NOC , renewing licenses every year  to these guilty industries.

10.  To order  Government of Karnataka , to pay two  crores compensation to  deceased boy Harsha’s family  immediately  and  to recover  it from the guilty industrialist.

11.  To treat this as a PIL and to issue writ of mandamus to concerned officials in the current case.

 

 

FOR WHICH ACT OF KINDNESS, THE PETITIONER SHALL BE DUTY BOUND, EVER PRAY.

 

Dated :  19.04.2017……… ………………….FILED BY: NAGARAJA.M.R.

 Place :  Mysuru , India…………………….   PETITIONER-IN-PERSON

 

Shocking but true! Mysuru has no place for dumping industrial waste

 

Truth is like a bitter pill. It is tough to swallow. Mysuru, which has bagged the ‘Cleanest city’ award for two consecutive years, does not have an exclusive place for dumping industrial waste. Shocking but it’s true!

The industrial area in the Mysuru district does not have any specific place to dump the industrial waste or hazardous waste. As soon as the news of a 14-year-old boy Harshal, who succumbed with severe burns after stepping in to an open site at Sadanahalli, came to light, localites alleged that the boy may have died when he stepped in to the chemical and hazardous wastes that were dumped illegally in the open place.

City Today went on a reality check to identify where the chemical and industrial wastes are dumped in the city. We found that there is not even a single dumping yard or industrial waste disposal unit across the district.

There are over 11 industrial areas including Hebbal, Metagalli, Koorgalli, Belavadi and nearly 32,000 industries in the district but most of these industries do not have an earmarked place for dumping industrial wastes. Though there is a rule from the KIADB which states that at least 20 acres of land in all industrial area must be reserved for disposal of Hazardous waste, the concerned officials in the district have failed to act.

For more than a decade, Mysore industries Association (MIA) has been battling to bring a dumping yard in the district. In 2007, the MIA requested the KIADB to allot land to set up a waste disposal unit. However, in the year 2009, the state government allotted three acres of land near Koorgalli Industrial area and decided to grant the maintenance responsibility to MIA. But later, the KIADB handed over only part of the land from the allotted property. Realising the fact that the industrial waste can’t be disposed in the partial land, MIA requested the KIADB to at least provide 5 acre of land and the officials agreed orally. But nothing has happened so far.

Speaking to City Today, Secretary of MIA, Suresh Kumar Jain said, “There is no dumping yard or an industrial waste disposal unit in the district. Though we have met and discussed with the concerned officials to sanction a suitable place, the proposal is still in papers and hasn’t come in to force.”

“The issue was brought to the notice during single window meetings but no proper action has taken place till now,” he added.

Last year, Mysuru’s waste management scored over Chandigarh to clinch cleanest city title. It is high time for concerned officials to allot an exclusive place for dumping industrial waste in the district keeping health hazards in mind.

 

Mysuru: Boy's death - did currency note printing chemical wreak havoc?

 

Mysuru, Apr 18: It has been confirmed that waste containing water sensitive chemicals had claimed the life of a boy at Naganalli in the outskirts of the city.

A team of experts, led by the district administration, which collected samples of sand from the area, has sent them for laboratory testing. The team found that the temperature of sand at the spot, which is finer as compared to sand found in other areas in the village, has brown and grey hues. Temperature at the spot stands at 110 degree Celsius, which is quite high. Chairman of Karnataka State Pollution Control Board, Laxman, said that four samples from the spot and five from other areas around it have been collected and sent for testing. Geologists and environment pollution officials were among those who visited the area.

 

 

 

Some villagers have complained that discharge of poisonous chemicals by some factories located near this area has caused this catastrophe. Former chief minister of the state, H D Kumaraswamy, relying on certain sources, has placed the blame on the government mint in the city for the tragedy, duly accusing it of disposing off printing chemical waste at the spot. Secretary of Mysore Industries Association, Suresh Kumar Jain, also has supported this notion. He has alleged that the association had complained about the unscientific disposal of printing chemicals by Reserve Bank of India about five years back and that the Reserve Bank neither took steps to correct its mistakes nor did it establish waste processing plant.

Some scientists attribute this phenomenon to the presence of chemicals like Phosphorous and Sodium Hydrate. There have also been chances of graphite and lead having caused the death. The experts hope to receive test reports in about two weeks time. Senior environmental officer in Karnataka State Pollution Control Board here, K M Lingaraju, said that the officials were dumbstruck about the cause of fire in an open field where garbage or chemical were not found to have been strewn around. He also added that the place is far away from proper roads and that no tyre marks were found around the area.

In the meanwhile, district in-charge minister, H C Mahadevappa, announced an ex gratia of two lac rupees to the family of Harshal (14), who died of burns during his visit to the open field for defecation on Sunday. As Manoj (17) suffered burns after sitting on a heap of sand, Harshal, who had accompanied him, had pulled Manoj out. During this effort, Harshal reportedly fell into the heap and suffered severe burns.

Harshal's father, Murthy, who held the factories located around the area responsible for the death of his son, also criticized the officials for not doing their duty of taking steps against the guilty promptly. He wants the officials to at least wake up now to the danger posed by chemical waste and take preventive measures before the waste causes further devastation.

 

 

NSG   Team  in  Belavatha - Radio Active Waste ?

 

http://starofmysore.com/nsg-team-city-probe-belavatha-mystery-fire/  

 

 

Visakhapatnam Accident: Time For Strict Action

 — by E A S Sarma

 

To

Shri C K Mishra

Secretary

Ministry of Environment, Forests & Climate Change (MEFCC)

Govt of India

Dear Shri Mishra,

You are aware of the ghastly gas leak accident that took place at LG Polymers unit near Visakhapatnam in the early hours of 7-5-2020. Several persons in the vicinity of the accident site could not escape to safe places and got asphyxiated to death. Several others had to be hospitalised for serious health problems associated with their lungs, eyes, nose, skin etc. The impact of the toxic gases that got released from the accident site extended upto 5-10km from it. The disease burden caused by the accident will stay on for decades to come. In short, irrespective of the laws, the rules and the procedures in force, such an accident should shake the conscience of the nation and prompt those in authority to introspect and self-correct.

Initial reports suggest that the gases released in the accident predominantly comprise Styrene.

According to a study conducted by IIT, Mumbai (“Vizag gas leak: Styrene levels 2,500 times more on May 8: CSE Analysis” reported at https://mail.google.com/mail/u/0/tab=wm&ogbl#inbox/FMfcgxwHNMTsTdtrpdGPcnSWPrcFQqrM), Styrene levels in the air at several locations around the accident site shot up by more than 2,500 times compared to the safety threshold. If this were to be taken as an accurate estimate, exposure to this of the population residing within 5-10km of the site would have resulted in both short-term and long-term disease burdens. It would result in ailments associated with the lungs, the kidneys, the eyes and so on. Styrene is known to cause cancer. Considering the known toxicity of Styrene, it would also result in stunting the affected children’s mental abilities. All these social costs far outweigh the perceived benefits of giving a red carpet treatment such industrial activity.

Your Ministry cannot afford to assume the role of a passive onlooker in the case of the accident at LG Polymers or any other similar accident. You may have unwittingly or otherwise breached the Constitutional obligation of the State to protect the human rights of the citizens by facilitating ex post facto approvals for such potentially dangerous industrial units to operate.

Article 48A of the Constitution requires your Ministry as well as the State to protect the environment. Article 21 obligates the government to protect the citizen’s right to life. Article 39 directs the government to ensure the citizen’s good health.

In pursuance of Article 48A, your Ministry had brought in the Environment (Protection) Act [EPA] and issued several rules and notifications from time to time. The central theme of this statutory framework is to ensure that no industrial project is undertaken without understanding its adverse impact on the environment, without understanding its implications for the people’s health and without taking into confidence those likely to be affected. That is the rationale underlying the concept of prior Environment Clearance (EC) being obtained by a project proponent. If an industrial project gets implemented without an environmental impact appraisal and without public consultation and if your Ministry becomes a rubber stamp to “regularise” such projects, it will defeat the purpose of Article 48A and EPA.

Over the years, in the absence of a firm commitment to the letter and the spirit of Article 48A, I am afraid that your Ministry has gradually transformed itself from an independent regulatory authority into a an agency that provides a regulatory garb to thousands of hazardous industries and polluting industries that endanger the people’s lives, damage the environment and affect the people’s health.

The LG Polymers accident represents the tip of the iceberg of what is going happen in the case of several thousands of industrial units handling hazardous chemicals, not subject to any worthwhile regulatory scrutiny, beyond public accountability and operating without any meaningful oversight and monitoring.

The notifications issued by your Ministry such as SO 804(E) dated 14-3-2017 and SO 1030(E) dated 8-3-2018 that granted the largesse of ex post facto approvals  “condoned” many errant units that preempted a stringent technical scrutiny, avoided a strict environment impact appraisal procedure and escaped a public consultation process. Had your Ministry respected the letter and the spirit of Article 48A of the Constitution and respected the Precautionary Principle in environmental jurisprudence, ghastly accidents such the one that disrupted the lives of lakhs of people around the industrial unit of LG Polymers would not take place.

We seem to have learnt very little from the Bhopal gas tragedy and I doubt whether we will draw any lessons from the latest Visakhapatnam disaster. In the ultimate analysis, it is the people who are forced to pay the price for the extra-ordinary affection displayed by the rules towards the larger businesses.

A time has come when your Ministry can no longer pretend that the changes being made in the environment impact assessment procedures would subserve the public interest.

I refer to the Draft Notification issued by your Ministry in March, 2020 proposing far reaching “simplifications” and paving the way for ex post facto approvals.

In this connection, I have extracted below an observation made by the Hon’ble Supreme Court on 1-4-2020 in Civil Appeal No. 1526 of 2016

“The concept of an ex post facto EC is in derogation of the fundamental principles of environmental jurisprudence and is an anathema to the EIA notification dated 27 January 1994. It is, as the judgment in Common Cause holds, detrimental to the environment and could lead to irreparable degradation. The reason why a retrospective EC or an ex post facto clearance is alien to environmental jurisprudence is that before the issuance of an EC, the statutory notification warrants a careful application of mind, besides a study into the likely consequences of a proposed activity on the environment. An EC can be issued only after various stages of the decision-making process have been completed. 

Requirements such as conducting a public hearing, screening, scoping and appraisal are components of the decision-making process which ensure that the likely impacts of the industrial activity or the expansion of an existing industrial activity are considered in the decision-making calculus. Allowing for an ex post facto clearance would essentially condone the operation of industrial activities without the grant of an EC. In the absence of an EC, there would be no conditions that would safeguard the environment. Moreover, if the EC was to be ultimately refused, irreparable harm would have been caused to the environment. In either view of the matter, environment law cannot countenance the notion of an ex post facto clearance. This would be contrary to both the precautionary principle as well as the need for sustainable development “

While an ex post facto approval may enhance the “ease of doing business” as it is fashionable to describe it these days, it is simultaneously encouraging industrial units which are unsafe, which pollute and which damage the people’s heath. I would therefore earnestly request you to revisit the need for issuing the Draft Notification of March, 2020. instead of diluting the environment laws and procedures, in the public interest, it is necessary to strengthen them and introduce a greater sense of public accountability in environmental regulation.

I understand that there are thousands of industrial units which have escaped environmental scrutiny and are awaiting the munificence of your Ministry to “regularise” their dangerous existence. If you grant ex post facto approval for such units, you will only be paving the way for more and more such units to come up, defying any kind of scrutiny and monitoring. Please move away from the repugnant idea of such approvals and introduce professional systems of prior environmental scrutiny.

I would also request your Ministry to identify all such units that handle hazardous substances and all such units that cause heavy pollution and close then down if they have failed to be in strict compliance with the environmental norms. If you take the public into confidence, it will become easy for you in the process of identifying those units because it is the local communities that bear the brunt of pollution and risk.

I hope you will take immediate action on this.

Regards,

Yours sincerely,

E A S Sarma

Former Secretary to GOI

Visakhapatnam

 

Nanjangud turns Kapila toxic

 

Heavy metals from industrial estate pollute Cauvery tributary

The markers of chemical pollution are everywhere in and around Nanjangud, one of the State’s biggest industrial estates. Waterborne disease and “pollution-induced migration” are only some of the documented impacts among communities here.

But toxic effluents from the 532-acre estate — primarily lead from paper mills and also cadmium, chromium, copper and nickel, according recent studies — do not spare the Kapila, a Cauvery tributary on whose banks Nanjangud is situated.

If any further proof is needed, researchers at the University of Mysore have documented the accumulation of trace metals in freshwater fish in the Kapila in Nanjangud area, including zinc, iron, nickel, lead, cadmium and chromium, they report in the Journal of Pharmacy Research.

Not surprisingly, the water source has been classified in ‘C’ category (water needs treatment and disinfection for drinking) by the Karnataka State Pollution Control Board (KSPCB).

KSPCB officers, however, refute the charges that industrial pollution is a major problem in this town.

 

Edited, printed , published owned by NAGARAJA.M.R. @  # LIG-2   No  761, HUDCO  FIRST  STAGE , OPP WATER WORKS , LAXMIKANTANAGAR , HEBBAL

,MYSURU – 570017  KARNATAKA  INDIA     Cell : 91 8970318202

  WhatsApp  91  8970318202

 

 

Home page :

http://eclarionofdalit.dalitonline.in        

https://dalit-online.blogspot.com     

 

 Contact  :  editor@dalitonline.in   ,

 editor.dalitonline@gmail.com