Sunday, January 5, 2020

Contempt by Judges

DALIT   ONLINE 
Bi – weekly
Editor: Nagaraja.M.R.. Vol.16.....Issue.02........05/01/2020


Editorial : Contempt of Citizens  by Judges
-Who will  bell the cat ?

Our whole hearted  respect to whole judiciary,  honest few in judiciary,  we want to state  the following: Contempt of Court is used as a weapon by few judges to silence those seeking justice , equality.  While handling a case one  must look at  the issue raised not at the  social status of person raising it. Those persons may be wrong in the mode of presenting the cases , but one must look at the facts , root cause / issue. Judges & senior advocates are also human beings capable of doing exemplary deeds as well as prone to err just like others. There is a false notion that if one makes eloquent quotes , uses Latin lexicon he knows everything. Such people fail to understand and uphold  basic tenets of our constitution , what is the use of their oratory ?
1.Selection of judges is not transparent. Significant number of those selected are  related to seniors in one way or the other. They may be deserving but raises the question “ Are not any fit persons there in the bar who are not related to anybody but deserving ?”
2.A senior advocate by his privilege gets superfast hearing of his case at the cost of a poor litigant represented by a junior lawyer. For example a senior advocate is representing a movie producer in case related  to movie screening he gets priority over a junior advocate representing a person who has suffered police torture or his land grabbing by Mafia,  illegal dismissal from service ,etc. Thereby , Senior advocate & presiding judge will be violating the poor man's right of equitable justice. Due these senior advocates in some cases poor persons represented by junior lawyer are dead by the time of judgement or suffer irreparable loss. Who will bear the cost , responsibility for this injustice senior advocate or presiding judge ?
3.In India  millions of people are barely surviving  on a single piece meal a day, still they pay indirect tax to public exchequer. Judges enjoy  relatively huge salary , perks  still  judges  demanded more pay & perks. Don't they have human conscience  ?
4.Corruption is rampant  in judiciary  just like other wings of government.  This has been affirmed by former Supreme Court Judges themselves.  Therefore all the judgements are not sacrosanct. Some may be and some may not be.
When issue of corruption was raised Justice Karnan was silenced by contempt of Court  weapon , when  disparity  between senior & junior advocates was highlighted  advocate M J Nedumpara was silenced by the contempt of Court weapon. When  inhuman unjustified pay , perks  by high court judges was questioned  meghalaya journalist was Silenced by contempt of Court weapon.  It  clearly proves nervousness of those judges who are caught on the wrong foot.  What is needed is transparency of judiciary , logically looking at the core issue raised. If the way of presenting the case is wrong  punish them but only after settling core issue not by silencing the whistleblower. By silencing whistleblowers those judges are  themselves  making contempt of the  very August office they hold , making contempt of constitution of India  and  contempt of  citizens of India,  what legal punishment for those erring judges ? Who will bell the cat ?



Why The kith And Kin Of Judges Being Mostly Considered For Appointments? Asks SCBA President, If A Judge’s Child Has Calibre, He/She Can Become A Judge: CJI
Excerpt from 2017  article


CJI Khehar also denies his son is on any state government panel
The Independence Day ceremony at the Supreme Court lawns today became a venue of some “polite” exchange between Supreme Court Bar Association President R S Suri and Chief Justice J S Khehar regarding children of judges or retired judges becoming judges and “80% of government panels being filled with sons and daughters of judges.
It all started when SCBA President Suri in his speech while reminding Law Minister Ravi Shankar Prasad and Chief Justice J S Khehar who were on the dais “several matters of concern” said "then there is one issue again an empirical..that why most of the judges who become HC judges are sons of previous judges. Why is that 80% of panels are filled with sons and daughters of the judges? These things are there but some empirical but some logical things have to be there so that we give some chance for other people also to come up the ladder because they are able and capable”
"Why is that the kith and kin of judges have the panels and are being considered for appointment as judges. Time has come that judiciary takes itself a ‘Sankalp Parva’ to clean the system of the 3rd wing, which is the most important one in upholding the constitutional values", he said.



RTI - Answer  Honourable  CJI  SCI & Chairman  NHRC

Refer  RTI  request nos :
JUSTC/R/2019/52664
NHRCM/R/2019/50678


Since 1990 , I as a citizen of India have brought to notice of SCI various crimes  hoping for justice to the  suffering public. Supreme court of India has enough time to judge trivial issues concerning movies , cricket , etc  but it doesn’t  have time to judge public  issues concerning national security , accountability of judges , police , public servants  in all these 28 years.  After repeatedly appealing for justice , powers that be have meted out injustices to me personally to silence me. SCI has failed in it’s duties  since 28 years , but judges are taking  hefty pay , perks from our money , public money  without feeling of shame or guilt.

Hereby , I request Honourable CJI , SCI to  provide information  by answering  following questions :

1. Since 1990 how many applications of PIL , RTI are received by SCI from me  NAGARAJA M R ?
2. How many show cause notices  are served to CJI , SCI  by Nagaraja M R , since 1990 ?
3. Details of action taken in each case. If not why ?
4. Why compensation amount is not yet paid by CJI , SCI to NAGARAJA M R , till date ?
5. How CJI , SCI is going to  protect the lives , civil rights of NAGARAJA M R & his family members ?  If anything untoward happens to NAGARAJA M R & his family members  CJI , SCI  is responsible together with jurisdiction police & district magistrate.
6. Why no  criminal legal prosecution of CJI , police , public servants  for their failure of duties ?
7. Honourable CJI , SCI   read  full case details at following web sites & honestly   ANSWER :
             
https://sites.google.com/site/dalitoonline/answer-cji---loya-murder     ,                   
 https://sites.google.com/site/dalitoonline/interrogate-chief-justice

8. What action taken against police who tortured threatened witnesses to give false
statements before court in sohrabuddin fake encounter case in first instance due to which
innocents suffered in jail for years? What action against presiding judges , advocates of the
case who failed to protect witnesses ?
9. In Gauri Lankesh murder case suspects are alleging that they are being tortured to give
confessions as per police diktat ? What action against police officials ?
10. If at all police , judges , advocates accept 3rd degree TORTURE as right method to elicit truth
why not CJI DIPAK MISHRA is subjected to 3rd degree TORTURE to elicit truth in fake affidavit
case , prasad college case , kalikho pul case and why not 3rd degree TORTURE of police
informing aiding dawood ibrahim , police doing dacoity at yelwal mysuru , DGP involved in
lottery scam ?
11.When police can subject a commoner alleged of small crimes like theft of hundred rupees
to 3rd degree TORTURE why not police , judges , advocates , politicians alleged of anti
national crimes , theft of crores of rupees , cheating , contempt of court / constitution , sex
crimes , crimes against women SC / ST subjected to 3rd degree TORTURE?
12.Why not 3rd degree TORTURE of Karnataka high court judges involved in mysore roost resort
sex scandal to elicit truth?
13. I have suffered numerous injustices for raising issues of public concern , national security.
As a result i was threatened , physically assaulted, murder attempts made on me , my news
paper closed , my job opportunities illegally snatched away, press accreditation denied , my
human rights , FUNDAMENTAL rights repeatedly violated. It is the duty of supreme court of
india to safeguard protect the rights of all indian citizens , but they failed to do their duties.
Paradoxically after appealing to SCI only more injustices were meted out to me. Are SCI
Judges hand in glove with anti nationals , criminals ? Why not 3rd degree TORTURE of SCI
Judges to elicit truth ?
14.Why not 3rd degree torture of past CBI Director Sinha who met representative of accused in
his official residence more than 20 times ?
15. Why not 3rd degree torture of crony Advocates who threaten truth seekers, to curry favors
with corrupt judges , police & powers that be ?
Please give information regarding above points and also read PIL at following web page.

https://www.scribd.com/document/336585411/FIRST-Answer-Judges-Police  ,

https://sites.google.com/site/dalitoonline/witness-protection-3rd-degree-torture   ,

https://sites.google.com/site/sosevoiceforjustice/interrogate-cji-dgps ,

16. Is powers that be and indian intelligence agencies behind assassination of late pm rajiv gandhi ?
17. As I  raised my voice seeking justice , proper enquiry of rajiv gandhi assassination before supreme court of india  I have personally suffered more injustices . Are SCI judges hand in gloves with assassins ?
18. Police complaints I made were not acted upon, keeping it pending for years without seeking permission from home ministry for sanction of legal prosecution of high & mighty, why ? Are they also hand in glove with criminals ?
19. why difference in law enforcement  for same type of crime like sexual harassment against one by low ranking judge another by  high court , supreme court Judges?
20. Why principals of PES ENGINEERING COLLEGE & NIE ENGINEERING COLLEGES , RBI NOTE PRESS , DISTRICT  JUDGES  OF  MYSURU & BANGALORE  CITY CIVIL COURT   ( who denied  job opportunities  to me  at the behest of criminal nexus ) were not interrogated  by  police  ?
21. It is the duty of SCI to uphold , protect constitutional rights & human rights of every indian citizen , why you are not doing your duty inspite of  taking  hefty  pay  perks ?
22. Why  press accreditation is denied to me while those covering  movies , lottery  , cooking are getting it ?
23. Inspite of repeated  human rights abuses against me and others and  fervent  appeals to NHRC  They have failed in their duties , citing various  clauses sub sections of law they have dismissed my appeals. Do NHRC  members  know  the basics  A B C D of human rights ? Only human beings understand  sufferings  of other human beings.
24. Police and intelligence officials have repeatedly  interrogated me based on my complaint. They never interrogated  the accused ? Why ?
25. Few police even threatened me , where  was their bravery against  mighty  criminals ?
26. Judges , Police who show their  might force  against  innocents , commoners  (  but same  judges , police are big zeroes before mighty criminals ) are  probable accomplices. I want  individual  wealth  details of  judges , police  personnel ( since past 20 years )  who interrogated me , who handled my complaints , appeals for justice and finally buried the cases under various pretexts.


Answer  Honourable  CJI  SCI , Honourable  Chairman , NHRC &  Honourable  DG & IG of  Police  GOK

To
Honourable Chairman
National Human Rights Commission
New Delhi.

Honourable Sir,

Since 1990 , I as a citizen of India have brought to notice of SCI , NHRC & Police various crimes  hoping for justice to the  suffering public. Supreme court of India has enough time to judge trivial issues concerning movies , cricket , etc  but it doesn’t  have time to judge public  issues concerning national security , accountability of judges , police , public servants  in all these 28 years.  After repeatedly appealing for justice , powers that be have meted out injustices to me personally to silence me. SCI has failed in it’s duties  since 28 years , but judges are taking  hefty pay , perks from our money , public money  without feeling of shame or guilt.

Hereby , I request Honourable CJI , SCI , Honourable Chairman , NHRC & Honourable DG & IG of Police , Government of Karnataka  , to  provide information  by answering  following questions :

Subject : REPLY / OBJECTIONS in Case No. 888/10/15/2014

Following points are my reply / objections to case closure refer your letter dated 18.09.2018. My whole hearted respects to honest few in judiciary , police & public service.

1. Since 1990 how many applications of PIL , RTI are received by SCI , NHRC & Karnataka Police from me  NAGARAJA M R ?
2. How many show cause notices  are served to CJI , SCI  by Nagaraja M R , since 1990 ?
3. Details of action taken in each case. If not why ?
4. Why compensation amount is not yet paid by CJI , SCI or NHRC to NAGARAJA M R , till date ?
5. How CJI , SCI  & NHRC are  going to  protect the lives , civil rights of NAGARAJA M R & his family members ?  If anything untoward happens to NAGARAJA M R & his family members  CJI , SCI  is responsible together with NHRC , jurisdiction police & district magistrate.
6. Why no  criminal legal prosecution of CJI , NHRC Chairman , police , public servants  for their failure of duties ?
7. Honourable CJI , SCI  , Honourable Chairman , NHRC & Honourable DG & IG of Police , Government of Karnataka  read  full case details at following web sites & honestly   ANSWER :

 https://sites.google.com/site/dalitoonline/answer-cji---loya-murder      ,           

https://sites.google.com/site/dalitoonline/interrogate-chief-justice  ,

8. Statement of police are half truth.
9. Statements / complaints made by me in my e mails / e news paper when I was in free & fair atmosphere holds good forever. It overrides statements made before police.
10. Some of the complaints made by me are pending since years/  decades. Other than police summoning me repeatedly to question me , to take my statements , What else they have done?  Just based on my statements before police , police have filed case closures  subsequently NHRC / SCI   also  followed the  same course.  what other action did they take for years ? Did police , NHRC / SCI summon high & mighty people mentioned in my complaints even once ? Did they take their statements ? Did they conduct investigations? What are the outcome of those investigations ? Did police find out the persons & their motives for silencing me ? Did police police take action against them ? Have police formally requested government & supreme court for sanction to enquire powerful people enjoying legal immunity privileges? If not why ?
11. Fed up with inaction of police for years and understanding their practical difficulties I have appealed to NHRC and Supreme Court of India by way of PILs seeking justice. Till date I have not got justice from NHRC or SCI.
12. Public servants take thousands of rupees salary , perks every month on time without fail from public exchequer. But some of them don't do their duties properly in time. public made to wait for justice indefinitely for years together.
13. Is it not the duty of government to protect life , rights of all citizens and to enable them to perform their duties ? If goverment cannot do it’s  duties  then such public servants are  waste bodies.
14.  Does not the  denial of justice in the above cases  to me  amount to cover up of crimes by police & judges ?
15. I have answered questions of police , IB number of times now it is the turn of police, judges to answer my questions seeking truth. Please read following web pages and answer within six weeks :
https://dalitsonline.blogspot.com/2018/08/torture-of-corrupt.html?m=1

16. In war soldiers  cut off food / medicine supplies to enemy troops to cripple them , to reduce their fighting strength. In the same way my job opportunities in NIE Engineering college mysore PES college mandya RBI Press Mysuru RPG Cables mysuru Mysuru court & Bangalore courts were denied illegally. Who was behind it ?
17. Who behind denying registration to my news paper & denying press accreditation to me ?
18. Who behind physical assaults on me , threats to me , blank calls to me , stalking over my  family ?
19. What action taken against those persons ?
20. I request you for justice , legal prosecution of guilty , legal prosecution of police and judges who by their inaction helped in crimes cover up.
21. As state police are not empowered hereby I request you for a  transparent  SIT probe monitored by NHRC & SCI.
22. Hereby I state if anything untoward happens to me or to my family members dependents NHRC will be jointly liable with CJI , jurisdiction police & District Magistrate for the crime.

23. Why i was not permitted to appear as an Amicus Curie before Jain commission of  enquiry  probing  Rajiv gandhi assassination case ?
24.  I have brought to the notice of SCI  land grabbing of hebbal lake , beml quarters lake, hootagalli lake in the very early stages. Due to your inaction grabbings took place continues till date. Are you not  complicit in the crimes ?
25. Why no proper action taken against management of RPG Cables for their crimes ?
26. Why i was not given legal aid to  pursue my cases in SCI ?
27. If a commoner murders a person it is a crime if the same act done by police is it not a crime ?
28. If a commoner gives a  false statement / false affidavit it is a crime , if the same act done by a judge, police, advocate is it not a crime ?
29. I have given list of crimes  committed  by judges , police , advocates to you earlier  , still no proper  legal action taken against culprits why ? Are the rules , law different for them ?
30. Few  advocates , police  , intellectuals ( ? ) have threatened me over phone , through social media , etc  to silence me. They are nothing but stooges , cronies of corrupt. Why no legal action against them for Obstructing my Fundamental Duties and  for violations of my fundamental rights , human rights ?
31. I have  appealed to SCI regarding  cases of atrocities against Dalits. Till date no proper legal action taken why ?
32. Are not the delays by you amount to denial of justice by way of time bar of case or death of  applicant ?
33. Why SCI has not utilised my services to apprehend criminals within public service ?

Date : 05.01.2020                     Thank you
Place : Mysuru                            Nagaraja Mysuru Raghupathi





Edited, printed , published owned by NAGARAJA.M.R. @  # LIG-2   No  761,
HUDCO  FIRST  STAGE , OPP WATER WORKS , LAXMIKANTANAGAR , HEBBAL
,MYSURU – 570017  KARNATAKA  INDIA     Cell : 91 8970318202
  WhatsApp  91  8970318202

Home page :
http://eclarionofdalit.dalitonline.in/      ,
https://dalit-online.blogspot.com/

Contact  :  editor@dalitonline.in      , editor.dalitonline@gmail.com

No comments:

Post a Comment